Wednesday, 18 November 2026 Our record: 73% called, 114 calls on file SearchSubscribe
Crypto and finance news. On the record.
Breaking
Prediction markets2 min read

Novig New York ruling says sports contracts are betting

The Novig New York ruling denied the exchange an injunction against state gambling laws, with a federal judge saying its sports contracts are not swaps.

Novig New York ruling says sports contracts are betting
Illustration: Called It

Another sports prediction exchange has lost in court in Manhattan. The Novig New York ruling, issued on November 10 by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon, denied the CFTC-registered exchange a preliminary injunction that would have kept New York's gambling laws away from its sports event contracts.

What happened

In August, Ludlow Exchange LLC, the company that runs Novig, filed suit against Attorney General Letitia James and officials of the state Gaming Commission. In a 35-page opinion, McMahon found Novig was unlikely to win on the merits. "The Court is not required to disregard common sense - Novig's sports event contracts are sports betting," she wrote, pointing to Novig's own public ambition to lead the world in sports betting.

The judge accepted that a game result can be an event or contingency under the Commodity Exchange Act, but found no link to a potential financial, economic or commercial consequence, which the law requires for a swap. Novig won CFTC designation as a contract market on June 16 and started offering sports contracts in New York on August 4, CryptoSlate said, citing the opinion.

McMahon also ruled on the alternative case. Even if the contracts were swaps, she reasoned, the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction would not stop New York from incidentally applying its gambling rules. She called the claimed conflict between federal and state law "a mirage" and said Novig could get a state license and use geofencing, as sportsbooks such as FanDuel do.

The opinion also noted Novig's history. Novig obtained a Colorado internet sports betting operator license in 2023 and later returned it and switching to an exchange model, RG reported. McMahon called Novig's claim that it could not comply with both federal and state law "ridiculous." The court had already refused Novig a temporary restraining order in August. Those details make the Novig New York ruling harder to read as a narrow technical loss.

Why it matters

The opinion went further than procedure. RG reported that McMahon said a CFTC order directing Kalshi to keep operating "smacks of a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee" to build a preemption claim. That language will sharpen the fight between states and the federal regulator, which we followed in the CFTC Kalshi charges story.

The Novig New York ruling also adds to a pattern. A Second Circuit panel had already refused injunctions pending appeal for Kalshi and Coinbase, and Novig faces separate cases in Missouri and Washington, including the one in our Novig Missouri lawsuit report. The order addresses only interim relief and leaves Novig's federal designation in place.

What's next

Novig filed a notice of appeal to the Second Circuit the same day. The appeals court's handling of that filing, and of the related Kalshi and Coinbase appeals, will decide whether exchanges can keep serving New York sports traders without a state license.

RG's summary of the opinion is here.

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.

More from Prediction markets

All prediction markets

The Morning Call.

The day's crypto and finance news, one call and one chart. Weekdays at 7am ET.