Senate Democrats CFTC letter demands reversal of geofencing order
A Senate Democrats CFTC letter asks Chair Michael Selig to drop his order that prediction markets stop blocking users state by state, saying it clashes with court rulings.

The fight over who regulates prediction markets has reached the Senate committee that oversees the CFTC. In a Senate Democrats CFTC letter sent on Monday, nine senators told Chair Michael Selig that his push to make platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket serve all 50 states "directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed."
What happened
The Wall Street Journal first reported the letter, The Defiant said, naming California's Adam Schiff, Minnesota's Amy Klobuchar and Michigan's Elissa Slotkin among the signatories. CoinDesk reported that it was signed by several Democrats on the Senate Agriculture Committee, which supervises the CFTC.
The target is the agency's Nov. 5 notice to designated contract markets. It gave exchanges 30 days to drop in-country geographic limits that breach its impartial-access rules, or to tell its Division of Market Oversight why that is not feasible. The underlying interpretation says eligible traders generally cannot be excluded because of where they live in the United States. Selig has argued that "derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale." Platforms including Kalshi and Polymarket hold designated contract market status with the CFTC, and Selig contends that this pre-empts state gambling enforcement. The notice also says exchanges should make sure intermediaries reaching their markets comply within the same period.
Why it matters
The senators' point is practical. Many platforms geofence because judges told them to. The letter notes that courts "have ordered platforms to cease offering various prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington, and on the land of two California tribes, and imposed geofencing requirements." Several federal appeals courts have sided with states against the federal regulator, CoinDesk said. An exchange caught between a court order and a CFTC directive faces risk either way.
Why does the Senate Democrats CFTC letter carry weight? Democrats will take the majority, and with it the Agriculture Committee's agenda, in less than two months, after the midterms. That gives them more say over CFTC budgets, hearings and nominees. The Defiant noted that the CFTC notice lets exchanges explain why they cannot comply, rather than ordering every block removed without exception, which could leave room for a compromise. Background on the original directive is in our story on the CFTC impartial access interpretation, and the agency is already in court over the issue in the CFTC Louisiana lawsuit.
What's next
The 30-day window from the Nov. 5 notice ends in early December, so exchanges must soon either drop state blocks or file explanations. Watch for the CFTC's reply, any change in tone from Selig and whether platforms quietly keep their geofences while citing court orders. The Senate Democrats CFTC letter also sets up a broader clash in the next Congress over whether federal law pre-empts state gambling rules for event contracts. CoinDesk's report is here.
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.