Peraire-Bueno MEV acquittal ends a first-of-its-kind Ethereum fraud case
The Peraire-Bueno MEV acquittal clears two MIT-trained brothers accused of taking $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in 12 seconds, after a judge found no material misrepresentation.

A closely watched test of how far fraud law reaches into blockchain trading has ended without a conviction. The Peraire-Bueno MEV acquittal, issued on Monday by U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan, clears Anton Peraire-Bueno and his brother James of wire fraud and related counts tied to a $25 million Ethereum exploit carried out in about 12 seconds.
What happened
Prosecutors said that in April 2023 the brothers, both computer programmers, ran a fast bait-and-switch against other traders' automated bots. They used lure transactions to draw in so-called sandwich bots and then exploited a weakness in MEV-Boost, software used by most Ethereum validators, to grab the bots' trades, according to Reuters reporting carried by The Jerusalem Post. MEV, or maximal extractable value, is the profit available from reordering or inserting transactions in a block. Prosecutors said the pair spent months planning how to tamper with the process that validates transactions before they are added to the chain. Both studied at MIT: Anton finished a computer science and engineering bachelor's in 2024, while James earned a similar degree in 2019 and a master's in aeronautics two years later, according to media reports cited by Reuters.
The pair were indicted in May 2024. A jury deadlocked after a trial in November 2025, and the court declared a mistrial. Rather than face a retrial, the defense asked the judge to acquit. Clarke agreed, ruling that the government failed to show that the brothers made any material misrepresentation, which wire fraud requires. "The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes," she wrote. She added that the trades did not take place on a regulated market whose rules prohibited such conduct.
Why it matters
The Peraire-Bueno MEV acquittal matters because the case was the first federal prosecution of its type. Prosecutors framed an on-chain strategy that turned other bots' code against them as theft. The judge did not endorse the trade; she said the charges chosen did not fit. That leaves open whether other laws could apply, but it narrows the use of wire fraud against exploits that rely on code behaviour rather than lies.
Industry advocates had pushed that line for a long time. Peter Van Valkenburgh, who runs advocacy group Coin Center, told The Block after the mistrial that the case was a "massive overstep." The ruling lands as U.S. courts are also weighing other trading disputes, such as the Cash Cat frontrunning claims, and as prosecutors pursue cases with clearer deception, like the FBI agent crypto theft plea.
What's next
A spokesperson for U.S. Attorney James McDonald, whose office ran the case, declined to comment, and lawyers for the brothers had no immediate comment, Reuters said. The government has not said whether it will appeal. For MEV searchers and validators, the Peraire-Bueno MEV acquittal is a signal that aggressive but code-based strategies may fall outside wire fraud, though civil suits and other charges remain possible. The Block's report is here.
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.