Thursday, 19 November 2026 Our record: 73% called, 116 calls on file SearchSubscribe
Crypto and finance news. On the record.
Breaking
Prediction markets2 min read

Kalshi Maryland appeal fails as Fourth Circuit backs state

Kalshi lost its Maryland appeal 2-1, as the Fourth Circuit let the state enforce its sports betting laws, the third of four appeals courts to side with states.

Kalshi Maryland appeal fails as Fourth Circuit backs state
Illustration: Called It

Another federal appeals court has sided with a state against prediction markets. The Kalshi Maryland appeal failed on Nov. 18, when a divided Fourth Circuit panel upheld a lower court's refusal to stop Maryland from enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi's sports event contracts.

What happened

The ruling in KalshiEX v. Martin is a one-line per curiam affirmance with three separate opinions. Judge Roger Gregory did not decide whether the contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. Assuming they were, he reasoned, Congress still had not plainly stripped Maryland of its power over gambling, and Kalshi could comply with both regimes by obtaining a state licence or not offering the contracts in Maryland.

Judge Stephanie Thacker went further, finding the contracts are not swaps at all. "What is happening here is sports betting," she wrote. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented, arguing that the contracts are swaps under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, and citing Third and Sixth Circuit readings that favour Kalshi.

The dispute began on April 7, when Maryland regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter. The company sued two weeks later, and the district court denied it an injunction on Aug. 1, CBS Baltimore reported.

Why it matters

CoinDesk counts this as the third of four appellate decisions to favour state oversight. Earlier in November, the Second Circuit likewise declined to shield Kalshi and Coinbase from New York and Connecticut while their appeals proceed. Kalshi's spokeswoman argued the split proves there is "no unified coherent legal argument" against prediction markets, but the clear majority of judges are ruling against the industry.

The timing is awkward. The CFTC has issued a 30-day demand that exchanges such as Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase offer contracts in all 50 states instead of geofencing those that object. Complying could mean defying federal court orders; refusing could put the venues at odds with their regulator. Federal authorities have also joined fights against states such as Arkansas, and the agency recently stayed Kalshi's Trump mention markets. The Kalshi Maryland appeal shows courts are not following Washington's lead.

Money is at stake for the state as well. RG reported that the state's licensed sportsbooks handled $710.1 million of wagers in October, producing $13.8 million in state revenue.

What's next

Attorney General Anthony Brown said Kalshi must now meet the same consumer standards as licensed sportsbooks. Kalshi has not said how it will respond, either to the ruling or to the CFTC's nationwide directive. After the failed Kalshi Maryland appeal, the company's options include seeking a rehearing before the full Fourth Circuit or pressing its case at the Supreme Court. With the circuits split, the question looks increasingly likely to end up there, and until it does, rules will differ from state to state. CoinDesk's report is here.

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.

More from Prediction markets

All prediction markets

The Morning Call.

The day's crypto and finance news, one call and one chart. Weekdays at 7am ET.